We’re a local print shop, so you’d expect us to say “always go local.” But the reality is more nuanced than that — and we think you deserve an honest take.
We’ve had customers come to us after bad experiences with big online services. We’ve also had people ask us about situations where, honestly, an online option made more sense for what they needed. Here’s how we actually think about it.
When Online Printing Services Make Sense
If you need fewer than 12 shirts, have a simple design, and aren’t particular about the exact garment, an online service can work fine. Sites like Custom Ink or Printful have improved their quality over the years, and for a one-off run where you just need something decent, they’re a reasonable option.
They also work well for print-on-demand — if you’re selling shirts through your own store and only want to print when someone orders, that model makes sense. We don’t do print-on-demand, so that’s not us competing with anyone; it’s just a genuinely different use case that we’re not the right fit for.
Where Online Printing Tends to Fall Short
The problem with ordering shirts from a website is that you’re shipping a file and hoping the output matches what you imagined. You can’t feel the shirt before you commit to 60 of them. You can’t call the person who actually printed your last order.
We’ve had customers come to us after receiving shirts from a large online service where the placement was off on half the run, or the color was noticeably different from the proof. The resolution process took weeks of back-and-forth emails and ended with a partial refund — but no shirts in time for their event. With a local shop, that conversation happens in person and gets resolved fast.
There’s also the garment quality question. Big online services use whatever blank is in their system. You often don’t get to choose the shirt style, weight, or fit — you just get what they stock. We let you pick from a range of blanks and will send you to a sample before you commit to a full run if you want to feel the fabric first.
The Price Comparison Is Closer Than You’d Expect
Online services often look cheaper in the shopping cart. But factor in shipping — especially rush shipping if your deadline is real — and the gap closes quickly. For orders of 36 or more shirts, our pricing is usually comparable or better, without the freight cost or the uncertainty about what’s going to show up.
For large runs of 100 or more shirts, local almost always wins on price, turnaround, and quality. The economics of screen printing favor volume, and a local shop passes that savings on without padding it back with shipping fees.
What We’d Actually Recommend
If you’re in Austin and need shirts for a business, event, band, school, or organization — get a real quote from a local shop first. See what the turnaround looks like. Ask if you can see samples. If the price is in the same ballpark as online, the local option is almost always the better choice.
If you’re ordering 6 shirts with a complicated full-color photo print and you’re not in a rush, an online DTG service might genuinely make more sense for your situation. We’ll tell you that if it comes up. We’d rather point you in the right direction than take an order that isn’t the right fit.
Leave a Reply